Research news
Peat, pine cone compost or soil: which grew more tomatoes?
In a greenhouse trial in Yunnan, China, tomatoes grown in bags of a peat mix gave an estimated 53,657.70 kg per hectare, against 38,425.10 kg in composted pine cone residue and 29,796.45 kg in greenhouse soil.
Most comparisons of growing mixes look at what goes into the bag and what comes off the plant at the end. A team at Yunnan Agricultural University in Kunming followed tomatoes in three very different root-zone materials from transplanting to ripe fruit, sampling plants and their roots every four weeks to see when the differences showed up (Chen et al., 2026).
What this means for your grow
In this trial, with the same plants, the same fertiliser and the same watering, the choice of mix made a large difference to the harvest: the peat mix out-yielded both alternatives. The authors suggest the peat mix may be preferred when the aim is maximum yield, and that pine cone compost needs closer watching of nitrogen and phosphorus during fruit fill. They also say it may offer a locally sourced way to use less peat, though its economic and environmental advantages over peat still need to be assessed. It was one cultivar, one season and one greenhouse, so treat it as a useful comparison rather than a rule for every mix.
What did the team do?
Tomato seedlings of the cultivar '22B' were transplanted, one per bag, into non-woven grow bags 35 cm across and 30 cm deep, each holding about 0.02 cubic metres of one of three materials:
- Greenhouse soil: the top 0 to 20 cm of soil from a tomato greenhouse at the university, with stones and plant debris removed.
- Pine cone compost: crushed and composted pine cone residues.
- Peat mix: imported white peat and domestic peat mixed at a volume ratio of 0.9:1, with perlite added at one part perlite to 15 parts substrate.
Every bag had a controlled-release fertiliser (Basacote Plus 6M) mixed through at 2 kg per cubic metre before planting, and no more fertiliser was added. All treatments got the same watering. The team pulled up three bags of each treatment at weeks 4, 8, 12 and 16 after transplanting to measure the root zone, root activity and plant dry matter, kept bags without plants as a comparison, and harvested ripe fruit from six plants per treatment for yield.
What did they find?
- Yield: estimated yield differed significantly between all three materials: 53,657.70 kg per hectare in the peat mix, 38,425.10 kg in pine cone compost and 29,796.45 kg in soil. The authors put the peat mix at 80.08% more than soil and 39.64% more than pine cone compost.
- More fruit, and heavier fruit, than soil: plants in the peat mix carried 14.50 fruits each, against 10.67 in soil, with pine cone compost in between at 12.50. Single fruits weighed 220.16 g in the peat mix and 211.37 g in pine cone compost, against 125.87 g in soil.
- Fruit shape did not change: fruit length, width and shape did not differ significantly between the three materials.
- Lighter and wetter: through the season both the peat mix and pine cone compost stayed much less dense than soil, and the peat mix generally held the most water, while the soil was the densest and driest.
- Pine cone compost led on some enzymes early: it generally showed higher activity of two enzymes in the material clinging to the roots (urease and sucrase) in early to middle growth, but in late growth the peat mix built up more plant dry matter, and at maturity it had accumulated the most nitrate nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium in the stems, leaves and fruit.
What could it mean?
The authors argue that how well a growing material performs depends on how its conditions line up with what the crop needs at each stage of growth, not on its starting properties alone. For greenhouse tomato production, they write that the peat mix may be preferred when maximising yield is the main aim, while pine cone compost calls for closer monitoring of nitrogen and phosphorus during fruit expansion (around week 12) so extra feeding can be given when needed. They add that composted pine cone residues may offer a locally sourced alternative to reduce peat use, but that their economic and environmental advantages over peat still need to be assessed. Because it was a single greenhouse trial, the result is most relevant to greenhouse growers and researchers comparing peat alternatives, rather than a proven recipe.
What were the limitations?
The authors note that the three materials differed a lot in their starting physical and chemical properties, so using one fertiliser regime for all of them could not separate the effect of the material's structure from the nutrients it already held. The trial used a single cultivar, in one growing season (May to September 2023), in a single greenhouse at Yunnan Agricultural University. Plant nutrients were measured only at maturity, and only as nitrate nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium in stems, leaves and fruit. The enzyme measurements show potential activity rather than actual rates in the bags.
Trial details
- Where: a single greenhouse at Yunnan Agricultural University, Yunnan, China.
- Who: College of Resources and Environment, Yunnan Agricultural University, Kunming, and the Key Laboratory for Improving Quality and Productivity of Arable Land of Yunnan Province.
- Crop: tomato (Solanum lycopersicum) cultivar '22B', from transplanting to fruit ripening.
- How long: seeds sown 5 April 2023 in 50-cell trays of commercial seedling mix; transplanted 26 May 2023; sampled at weeks 4, 8, 12 and 16 after transplanting; ripe fruit harvested from about week 14.
- System and substrate: non-woven grow bags (35 cm diameter × 30 cm height, about 0.02 m³), one plant per bag; greenhouse soil, composted pine cone residue, or white and domestic peat (0.9:1 by volume) with perlite (1:15). Starting pH 6.38 (soil), 6.54 (pine cone) and 6.41 (peat); starting EC 1.670, 0.610 and 1.125 mS·cm⁻¹. Substrates were left to equilibrate for 7 days before transplanting.
- Nutrition: Basacote Plus 6M controlled-release fertiliser at 2 kg·m⁻³ mixed in before transplanting, no further fertiliser.
- Pests and diseases: managed by standard practice with insecticides and a fungicide mix, applied when required, at least 7 days before destructive sampling.
- Design: 24 bags per planted treatment and 12 per unplanted control; three bags per treatment destructively sampled at each of four times; six plants per treatment for yield; ANOVA with Tukey-adjusted comparisons. Yield per hectare estimated from yield per plant at 17,000 plants·ha⁻¹.
- Results: fruit number per plant 10.67 (soil), 12.50 (pine cone) and 14.50 (peat); single fruit weight 125.87, 211.37 and 220.16 g; estimated yield 29,796.45, 38,425.10 and 53,657.70 kg·ha⁻¹.
- Funding and conflicts: Yunnan Provincial Key Science and Technology Project, Yunnan Provincial Science and Technology Talents and Platform Project, Yunnan Provincial Science and Technology Plan Project Agricultural Joint Special Project, a Major Special Project of the Department of Science and Technology of Yunnan Province, and the Yunnan Provincial 'High level Talent Training Support Plan'. The authors declare no commercial or financial conflict of interest.
- Publication: Frontiers in Plant Science 17:1986895, published 9 November 2026, https://doi.org/10.3389/fpls.2026.1986895. Licence: CC BY 4.0.
- Not reported in the paper: greenhouse temperature, humidity and lighting, the amount and timing of watering, fruit quality results (fruit were evaluated for quality traits, but no quality results are given), and costs.
Links
References
- Chen, Y., Li, Y., Zi, W., Chai, Y., Chen, J., & Shi, J. (2026). Tomato cultivation substrates differ in stage-dependent root zone–rhizosphere coordination and biomass allocation. Frontiers in Plant Science, 17, 1986895. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpls.2026.1986895
Visit Us In-Store: 2/322 Hobart Rd, Youngtown TAS