FREE SHIPPING icon
FREE SHIPPING

Orders over $499

RARE & EXOTIC PLANTS icon
RARE & EXOTIC PLANTS

Hard-to-find varieties

PREMIUM QUALITY icon
PREMIUM QUALITY

Only the best for your grow

chevron_left chevron_right
Horticulture Industry Updates

Research news

Which whitefly insecticides work alongside Amblyseius swirskii?

By Hydro Oasis ·

Several adult whiteflies with white wings and pale yellow bodies resting on the hairy green surface of a leaf, under magnification
Adult whiteflies (Bemisia tabaci) on a leaf, under magnification (not from this study). Bemisia tabaci from USDA 2. Photo: Stephen Ausmus, via Wikimedia Commons, Public domain.

In greenhouse cage trials on potted salvia in Florida, cyantraniliprole, flupyradifurone and afidopyropen cut whitefly numbers while the predatory mite Amblyseius swirskii kept breeding on the same plants.

Can you spray for whitefly without wiping out the predatory mites you released to fight it? A team from the University of Florida, the University of Georgia and the USDA Agricultural Research Service put seven insecticides to that test against the Mediterranean (MED) species of the whitefly Bemisia tabaci (biotype Q), a major pest in greenhouse ornamental production, where repeated insecticide use has raised concern about resistance (Jha et al., 2026).

What this means for your grow

If you rely on Amblyseius swirskii for whitefly, this study suggests the choice of insecticide matters, because with some products the mites kept breeding and with others they turned up only sporadically. In these cages, releasing the mites alongside an insecticide generally gave the strongest overall whitefly suppression. With two of the products, fewer mites were found in the combined cages, which the authors say may be down to the insecticide, a shortage of whitefly to eat, or both. The work was done on one whitefly colony on potted salvia in a research greenhouse, so it is a guide for building a rotation, not a promise of the same result in your crop.

What did the team do?

Salvia 'New Dimension Blue' plants were grown from seed, moved into 3.78 L pots and set up in mesh cages in a greenhouse at the USDA-ARS U.S. Horticultural Research Laboratory in Fort Pierce, Florida. Each cage of four plants was given 100 adult MED whiteflies a week for three weeks, and mite cages got 20 A. swirskii per plant on three occasions, starting a week after the first whiteflies went in.

Each insecticide was tested in four treatments: untreated, insecticide alone, mites alone, and mites plus insecticide. Insecticides were applied at label rates in week 0 (pymetrozine was sprayed again in week 4), as a foliar spray or a soil drench. For eight weeks, the team took five leaves from each cage each week and counted whitefly eggs, nymphs and adults, plus A. swirskii eggs and moving mites (nymphs and adults).

What did they find?

These are the average whitefly suppression figures (eggs and nymphs plus adults, compared with untreated cages) over the eight weeks, for mites alone, the insecticide alone and the two together:

  • Dinotefuran (a neonicotinoid, as a drench): 90%, 97% and 98%. The mites kept breeding alongside it, although moving mites were fewer in the combined cages in weeks 3 to 5.
  • Cyantraniliprole (drench): 80%, 94% and 96%. The mites kept breeding alongside it, and mite egg counts were no different with or without the insecticide, though moving mites were fewer in the combined cages.
  • Flupyradifurone (drench): 89%, 84% and 97%. As a foliar spray: 93%, 67% and 99%. Mite numbers were no different with or without the insecticide, whichever way it went on.
  • Afidopyropen: 92%, 93% and 99%, with no difference in mite numbers with or without the insecticide.
  • Pymetrozine (foliar): 94%, 48% and 98%. It was weak and inconsistent on its own, even after a second spray at twice the rate in week 4, but the mites kept breeding alongside it.
  • Pyrifluquinazon: 79%, 94% and 97%. Mites turned up only now and then in the combined cages.
  • Spinetoram plus sulfoxaflor (foliar): 62%, 83% and 83%. Mites were found only sporadically in the combined cages, and in different numbers from the mite-only cages.

The authors say the low mite numbers alongside pyrifluquinazon and spinetoram plus sulfoxaflor may come from the insecticide itself, from the mites running short of whitefly to eat, or both; the cage trials could not separate the two.

What could it mean?

The authors conclude that MED whitefly can be controlled without relying only on neonicotinoids, and name cyantraniliprole, flupyradifurone and afidopyropen as particularly strong candidates to use with A. swirskii. They see dinotefuran as a valuable standard to use strategically rather than routinely, pyrifluquinazon and the spinetoram plus sulfoxaflor mix as better suited to knockdown or clean-up than to programs built on ongoing mite releases, and pymetrozine as of limited use on its own. This is likely most useful to commercial ornamental growers and pest advisers planning insecticide rotations around predatory mites.

What were the limitations?

The authors note that no resistance tests were run, so the results describe this one MED colony rather than its resistance status. Mite compatibility was judged by whether mites could establish and breed on treated plants in greenhouse cages, which does not directly measure toxicity, sublethal effects or how long residues last. They call for testing of sequential treatment programs, repeated applications and performance in commercial greenhouses.

Trial details

  • Where: greenhouse at the United States Horticulture Research Laboratory, USDA-ARS, Fort Pierce, Florida, United States.
  • Who: University of Florida (Mid-Florida Research and Education Center, Apopka), The University of Georgia, and the USDA-ARS U.S. Horticultural Research Laboratory, Fort Pierce.
  • Crop: Salvia 'New Dimension Blue', grown from seed and kept in screened cages for about 8 weeks before the experiment.
  • Pest and predator: Western MED whitefly (Q2), a colony first collected from poinsettia in Syracuse, New York, in 2015, and checked regularly for purity; A. swirskii from Koppert Biological Systems.
  • How long: 8 weeks of weekly sampling (week 0 to week 7).
  • System and substrate: seedlings raised in Premier Pro-Mix General Purpose Growing Medium in trays, then transplanted to 3.78 L pots in mesh-screened cages (61 × 61 × 61 cm).
  • Climate: greenhouse temperature 21.1 to 31.1 °C; relative humidity 52.0 to 99.5%.
  • Nutrition: 50 mL per pot of Peters Professional 20-10-20 (325 ppm) once a week; irrigated as needed.
  • Treatments: dinotefuran, cyantraniliprole, pyrifluquinazon, flupyradifurone, pymetrozine, spinetoram plus sulfoxaflor and afidopyropen, each at label rates as a foliar spray or a drench (drenches about 100 mL per pot), with pymetrozine applied a second time in week 4 at twice the rate, compared with untreated, mites-alone and mites-plus-insecticide cages.
  • Design: randomised complete block design, six replicate cages of four plants per treatment; five leaves sampled per cage each week; whitefly eggs and nymphs counted on two leaf discs (about 1 cm2) per leaf, adults by the leaf-turn method. All assays except the dinotefuran one were run twice.
  • Statistics: generalised linear mixed models with a negative binomial distribution, Tukey-adjusted comparisons (α = 0.05), and corrected mortality by Henderson and Tilton's formula.
  • Results: average whitefly suppression for mites alone, insecticide alone and combined, in that order: dinotefuran 90%, 97%, 98%; cyantraniliprole 80%, 94%, 96%; pyrifluquinazon 79%, 94%, 97%; flupyradifurone drench 89%, 84%, 97%; flupyradifurone foliar 93%, 67%, 99%; pymetrozine 94%, 48%, 98%; spinetoram plus sulfoxaflor 62%, 83%, 83%; afidopyropen 92%, 93%, 99%.
  • Funding and conflicts: the Farm Bill; NIFA, EPA, USDA/FDACS Specialty Crop Block Grant Program; USDA-ARS Floriculture and Nursery Research Initiative; and the IFAS/UF Line Item grants program. The authors declare no commercial or financial conflict of interest.
  • Publication: Frontiers in Insect Science 6:1925775, published 18 November 2026, https://doi.org/10.3389/finsc.2026.1925775. Licence: CC BY 4.0.
  • Not reported in the paper: lighting and day length, CO2, the pH and EC of the feed, the potting medium after transplanting, the dates of the trials, and any effect on plant growth or flowering.

Links

References
  1. Jha, V., Kakkar, G., Dahal, S., Osborne, L. S., & McKenzie, C. L. (2026). Neonic stewardship for MED Bemisia tabaci management: evaluating insecticide alternatives and biological control compatibility in greenhouse ornamentals. Frontiers in Insect Science, 6, 1925775. https://doi.org/10.3389/finsc.2026.1925775

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.